Nose

Aromas Faults
10 Exceptionally Complex/Secondary/Tertiary aroma 10 No Faults
9 Very Complex Secondary/Tertiary aroma 9 Possible faults :- High volatility 4 parts/million+
8 Complex Secondary aroma 8 Volatility/Excessive Sulphur/Mercaptan
7 Obvious Secondary aroma 7 Musty/Corked/Fusel/Baked/Cooked
6 Subdued Primary aroma 6 Jammy/Geranium/Hydrogen Sulphides
5 Very subdued aroma
5 Mousey/Sauerkraut/Rubbery/Oxidized
4 Commercial 4 Goaty/Medicinal/Plastic/Pomase
3 Simple 3 Putrid/Weedy/Unripe
2 Indiscernible 2 *note:- Take 1 point off for each fault
1 Neutral 1 Take 2 points off for bad faults.
Variety
Intensity
10 Subtle varietal character 10 Pungent/Positive
9 Very subtle varietal character 9 Very powerful
8 Delicate varietal 8 Powerful
7 Very light 7 Very Strong
6 Light
6 Strong
5 No varietal character
5 Delicate/discernible
4 Moderate varietal character 4 Just discernible
3 Strong varietal character 3 Frail
2 Very strong character
2 Very Frail
1 Powerful character 1 Indiscernible